The Tests That Work: What High-Performing Shopify Merchants Do Differently

One of the biggest privileges of working at ABConvert is seeing how hundreds of Shopify merchants—ranging from scrappy startups to scaling giants—use A/B testing to make sharper, faster, and more profitable decisions.

‍

Some merchants run experiments that drive serious ROI. Others stall, drop off, or gather dust in the “drafts” section.

‍

After analyzing over 4,000 experiments launched on ABConvert in the past 90 days, I wanted to share some of the biggest patterns I’ve seen—and what high-performing merchants are doing differently.

‍

The Merchants Who Win Don’t Just Test—They Complete it

The first signal we look at? Completion rate.

‍

Across all experiment types, we found that the merchants who consistently finish their tests (and let them run long enough to collect real data) are the ones growing faster.

‍

For example:

• Price tests had an 84% completion rate and averaged about 3.9 days in duration.
• Shipping tests were close behind, with 83% completion rate and a similar test duration (~3.6 days).
• But checkout UI tests? Only 20% get completed, and they run for weeks (avg. 29 days) before getting abandoned.

‍

Lesson: Speed to learn is a real advantage. The best merchants launch fast, wait smart, and finish strong.

‍

How Long Should a Test Run?

A common mistake we see is merchants either:

• Calling a test “too early” (e.g. within 24–48 hours), or
• Letting a test run indefinitely, collecting stale or diluted data.

‍

From our data, here’s the sweet spot:

• Price and content tests: ~4 days
• Template, theme, and URL redirect tests: ~2.8–3.5 days
• Tests longer than a week often see drop-off in traffic consistency or internal follow-through.

‍

Our rule of thumb: Plan for 3–5 days. It’s enough time to gather statistically meaningful results—especially if you’re testing on higher-traffic products or collections.

‍

Test Types That Work—and Ones That Need Help

Here’s where things get really interesting.

‍

We broke down test success not just by type, but by duration and completion rate. Here's what we found:

Test Types That Work—and Ones That Need Help

It’s clear: merchants have the most success with quick-to-launch, high-visibility tests like pricing and content. These are directly tied to conversions and easier to measure.

‍

Meanwhile, checkout UI tests often run long and get dropped. This isn’t surprising—they usually involve more theme complexity, dependencies on Shopify Plus, or require deeper QA.

‍

Advice: Start with tests you can deploy quickly and see clear results from—especially pricing, template, or content variants. Save deeper customization for when your team has testing muscle.

‍

Where Tests Go Wrong (And How to Prevent It)

We reviewed dozens of failed or abandoned experiments and noticed a few common culprits:

1. Unclear success criteria
2. If you don’t know what metric defines success—conversion rate, AOV, clicks—you can’t confidently declare a winner.
3. Weak or unbalanced variants
4. We’ve seen “price test” groups where one price was $34.00 and the other was... $34.00. No variation = no insights.
5. Poor test setup or broken logic
6. A test with bad targeting rules, invalid theme integrations, or misaligned product URLs won’t even get to the data stage.
7. Lack of patience for QA (esp. theme checks)
8. Price tests require us to analyze your theme to make prices dynamically update. It takes 1–2 days max, but some merchants rush past it or give up early—especially on weekends.

‍

That’s why we always recommend starting with our Best Practices Checklist and onboarding guides.

‍

Final Takeaways: Test Like the Best

If you want to test like our top-performing merchants, here’s your cheat sheet:

• Finish your tests. Even imperfect tests are better than unlaunched ones.
• Plan for 3–5 days. That’s the real window where most winning insights emerge.
• Start with test types that are fast, simple, and directly tied to revenue.
• Define success before you launch. If you don’t know what winning looks like, you’ll never find it.
• Be patient with technical steps. Theme checks and clean setups are worth the wait.

‍

You’ve got hunches.

‍

We’ve got the data engine to back them up.

‍

Let’s test smarter—together.