When to A/B Test: The Surprising Timing Trick that Analyzing 10,000+ Tests Taught us About Faster Growth

If you’ve been A/B testing without considering when to run your experiments, you might be overlooking a crucial factor in optimizing your store's performance.

‍

In this guide, we delve into how Shopify merchants leverage timing to their advantage, based on over 10,000 real A/B tests conducted in 2024 through ABConvert.

‍

Let's explore the testing patterns that top-performing merchants use to consistently enhance conversion rates and revenue.

‍

Summer Slump? More Like CRO Goldmine

Many stores perceive June through September as the off-season. Traffic slows, revenue dips, and testing often takes a backseat.

‍

However, merchants utilizing ABConvert saw a distinct increase in testing activity during this period. Leading brands used the quieter months to:

• Refine pricing across product lines
• Optimize UX components like review modules or product videos
• Test new shipping strategies or free shipping thresholds

‍

Why it works: Testing during slower months allows merchants to validate high-impact hypotheses before peak season. This pre-optimization pays off when traffic increases.

‍

“We treated the summer as our CRO lab. By November, we knew exactly which price points and messages converted.” — Shopify merchant using ABConvert

‍

For a comprehensive understanding of A/B testing strategies tailored for Shopify merchants, refer to Shopify's Complete Guide to A/B Testing.

‍

Q4 Is for Execution, but Testing Still Matters

As traffic surged in November and December, merchants largely paused high-effort tests. However, one type of experiment increased: URL Redirect Tests.

‍

These were commonly used to:

• Test which landing pages converted best, such as "Holiday Gifts" versus "Best Sellers"
• Redirect visitors to different product collections
• Run listicle versus advertorial landing page comparisons

‍

This lightweight test type enabled merchants to fine-tune holiday campaigns without disrupting core templates or themes.

‍

Tip: Save your complex experiments—like price and shipping changes—for Q2 and Q3. In Q4, focus on campaign-level tests that are quick to set up and easy to analyze.

For additional insights into effective e-commerce A/B testing practices, consider BigCommerce's Step-By-Step Guide to Ecommerce A/B Testing.

‍

Why Launching on Monday Is a CRO Power Move

One of the clearest signals in the data was the performance difference by day of the week.

Across the entire dataset, Tuesday was the highest-traffic day for Shopify stores. That means tests launched on Monday captured the full Tuesday cycle, enabling better statistical confidence and faster decision-making.

‍

Your testing calendar should look like this:

• Launch new experiments every Monday morning
• Let the test run through the week with consistent traffic
• Analyze results after a full week cycle

‍

This rhythm not only improves your velocity but also brings discipline to your CRO program.

‍

The 3-Test Rule: A Healthy Baseline for Shopify CRO

The average ABConvert user launched three A/B tests per month in 2024. This cadence is a solid benchmark for any merchant looking to grow consistently without overloading their team or analytics.

‍

Even if your store has lower traffic, focusing on one test per week ensures you’re always learning and iterating. Platforms like ABConvert’s Analytics Dashboard can help you generate new ideas and understand results faster.

‍

Final Word: Testing Timing Is a Growth Lever

Many brands focus exclusively on what to test, overlooking the significance of when to test. Our data indicates that timing is a key success factor in conversion optimization.

‍

Use these insights to your advantage:

• Test during summer when competition is lower and attention is higher
• Launch tests on Mondays to harness peak traffic
• Keep Q4 testing light and tactical

‍

Aligning your testing with your store’s traffic patterns and the e-commerce calendar enables you to make informed decisions and achieve compounding results.

‍

Ready to Build a High-Impact Testing Calendar?

👉 Install ABConvert to start testing smarter today.

‍